PRISMA 2020 → RevAIse mapping

Maps all 27 PRISMA 2020 items (Page MJ et al. BMJ 2021;372:n71) to RevAIse model slots, and records which are machine-checkable as SHACL versus prose-judgment items.

Constraint type: presence = sh:minCount 1 on the named slot. Checkable: yes = SHACL shape implemented · no = prose judgment, not machine-checkable. Status: ✅ done.

Title / Abstract

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
1	Title	Review	review_title	presence	yes	✅
2	Abstract	Review	review_abstract	presence	yes	✅

Introduction

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
3	Rationale	ReviewNarrative	rationale	presence	yes	✅
4	Objectives	Protocol	research_question	presence	yes	✅

Methods

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
5	Eligibility criteria	Protocol	eligibility_criteria	presence	yes	✅
6	Information sources	SearchStage	databases	presence	yes	✅
7	Search strategy	SearchStage	search_queries	presence	yes	✅
8	Selection process	ScreeningStage	screening_protocol	presence	yes	✅
9	Data collection process	ExtractionStage	extraction_protocol	presence	yes	✅
10a	Data items — outcomes	ExtractionStage	extraction_forms	presence	yes	✅
10b	Data items — other variables	ExtractionStage	extraction_forms	presence	yes	✅
11	Study risk-of-bias assessment	RiskOfBiasAssessmentStage	rob_protocol	presence	yes	✅
12	Effect measures	SynthesisStage	effect_measures	presence	yes	✅
13a	Synthesis methods — eligibility	SynthesisStage	synthesis_protocol	presence	yes	✅
13b	Synthesis methods — data preparation	SynthesisStage	synthesis_methods	presence	yes	✅
13c	Synthesis methods — display	SynthesisStage	synthesis_visualizations	presence	yes	✅
13d	Synthesis methods — methods	SynthesisStage	synthesis_methods	presence	yes	✅
13e	Synthesis methods — heterogeneity	SynthesisStage	heterogeneity_assessment	presence	yes	✅
13f	Synthesis methods — sensitivity	SynthesisStage	sensitivity_analyses	presence	yes	✅
14	Reporting bias assessment	SynthesisStage	publication_bias_assessment	presence	yes	✅
15	Certainty assessment	SynthesisStage	evidence_grading	presence	yes	✅

Results

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
16a	Study selection — flow diagram	FlowDiagram	records_identified	presence	yes	✅
16b	Study selection — excluded studies	ScreeningStage	screening_rounds	presence	yes	✅
17	Study characteristics	Review	literature_records	presence	yes	✅
18	Risk of bias in studies	LiteratureRecord	risk_of_bias	presence	yes	✅
19	Results of individual studies	LiteratureRecord	study_results	presence	yes	✅
20a	Results of syntheses — contributing studies	SynthesisStage	meta_analyses	presence	yes	✅
20b	Results of syntheses — statistical results	SynthesisStage	meta_analyses	presence	yes	✅
20c	Results of syntheses — heterogeneity	SynthesisStage	meta_analyses	presence	yes	✅
20d	Results of syntheses — sensitivity analyses	SynthesisStage	sensitivity_analyses	presence	yes	✅
21	Reporting biases	SynthesisStage	publication_bias_assessment	presence	yes	✅
22	Certainty of evidence	SynthesisStage	evidence_grading	presence	yes	✅

Discussion

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
23a	Discussion — interpretation	ReviewNarrative	discussion_interpretation	presence	yes	✅
23b	Discussion — evidence limitations	ReviewNarrative	discussion_evidence_limitations	presence	yes	✅
23c	Discussion — process limitations	ReviewNarrative	discussion_process_limitations	presence	yes	✅
23d	Discussion — implications	ReviewNarrative	discussion_implications	presence	yes	✅

Other information

PRISMA item	Topic	RevAIse class	RevAIse slot	Constraint	Checkable	Status
24a	Registration — number	Protocol	registration_id	presence	yes	✅
24b	Registration — protocol URL	Protocol	registration_url	presence	yes	✅
24c	Registration — amendments	Protocol	amendments	presence	yes	✅
25	Support / funding	Review	funding_sources	presence	yes	✅
26	Competing interests	Review	conflicts_of_interest	presence	yes	✅
27	Data availability	Review	data_availability	presence	yes	✅

Notes

Items 10a and 10b both map to extraction_forms: the extraction form defines all data items collected (outcomes and other variables). Items 20a–20c map to meta_analyses because each MetaAnalysis object contains contributing study characteristics, statistical results, and heterogeneity statistics. Items 13f and 20d both map to sensitivity_analyses; items 14 and 21 to publication_bias_assessment; items 15 and 22 to evidence_grading — the SHACL generator deduplicates these within each NodeShape.